When a vacancy attracts very few suitable applicants, salary is not always the first thing employers question. They may revisit the job description, adjust the experience requirements or widen their search. But sometimes the issue is simpler: the salary on offer does not reflect what candidates with the required experience can command in the current market.
The gap between budget and market value
Salary benchmarking is an important part of workforce planning, but it needs to reflect the role being recruited rather than relying on a broad industry average.
Two professionals with the same job title can have very different levels of experience, technical knowledge and responsibility. A Business Analyst working on routine process improvements, for example, may have a very different salary expectation to someone leading requirements across a complex ERP transformation.
The same applies across specialist technology roles. Experience with a particular platform, implementation methodology or business environment can influence a candidate’s market value.
Employers need to consider the actual requirements of the position, including the level of expertise, responsibilities, location and current demand for those skills.
A salary based on an outdated benchmark or a role with a similar title may not be enough to attract the experience the business is looking for.
What happens when the budget is too low?
When a salary falls below candidate expectations, employers can encounter several problems.
- A smaller pool of suitable candidates: Experienced professionals are unlikely to be attracted to a role that does not reflect their current market value, particularly if they are already employed and not actively looking to move.
- Longer recruitment processes: If the budget is too restrictive, hiring managers may spend weeks reviewing applications that do not meet the requirements or interviewing candidates who ultimately decline the offer.
- Compromises on experience: Some businesses respond by looking for candidates with less experience or reducing the technical requirements of the role.
Candidate expectations go beyond salary
Salary remains a significant factor when professionals consider a move, but it is not always the only deciding factor.
Candidates will also assess the responsibilities of the role, the technology they will work with, opportunities for progression, flexibility and the wider working environment.
For example, a professional may consider a slightly lower salary if the opportunity offers exposure to a major transformation programme, a clearer career path or greater flexibility. Equally, a higher salary may not be enough to secure someone if the role comes with unrealistic expectations or limited development opportunities.
This is why employers need to understand the full proposition they are offering.
If the salary is below the market rate, there needs to be a realistic understanding of what else might make the opportunity attractive. Benefits and flexibility can strengthen an offer, but they should not be treated as a guaranteed substitute for a significant gap in base salary.
How should businesses approach salary benchmarking?
Before advertising a vacancy, employers should take time to understand what the role is likely to cost in the current market.
A few considerations can help:
- Benchmark the actual role: Look at the responsibilities, level of seniority and specialist skills required, rather than relying solely on job title comparisons.
- Consider the available talent pool: Some technical specialisms are more competitive than others. The more specific the experience required, the more important it is to understand candidate availability and salary expectations.
- Review the full package: Consider benefits, bonus structures, flexibility, pension contributions and progression opportunities alongside base salary.
- Build in some flexibility: A fixed budget can limit the ability to secure an exceptional candidate. Where possible, establish a realistic salary range and understand what would justify the upper end.
- Review expectations during recruitment: If suitable candidates consistently fall outside the budget, it may be time to revisit the salary rather than continuing with the same approach.
Getting the salary right before you start recruiting
An unrealistic salary budget can have a knock-on effect across the entire recruitment process. It can reduce the number of suitable candidates, increase time to hire and leave businesses struggling to secure the experience they need.
This does not mean employers should automatically increase salaries whenever recruitment becomes difficult. It means understanding whether the budget is competitive for the skills and responsibilities being requested, and being prepared to adjust the approach where necessary.
The question is not simply whether you can afford the salary. It’s whether you can afford not to offer it.
At Engage, we work across Tech and Business Transformation, giving us insight into the expectations of professionals working across specialist technology and transformation roles.